Custom Search

Monday, September 19, 2011

The Critics at The Arts Desk Reveal Their Latest Grand Opera Reviews

By Steve Alexander


Puccini and Carl Maria von Weber are the star players in the latest offering from the world of grand opera from The Arts Desk.

The astonishing grand opera 'Der Freischtz' by Carl Maria von Weber performed at the penultimate night of the BBC Proms instead of the traditional Beethoven's Ninth. With its dark, dramatic Gothicism, the piece was hugely influential in the 19th century and enjoys an impressive reputation but a slightly less grand performance history.

Using the score rearranged by Berlioz, the great classical archaeologist Sir John Eliot Gardiner and his Orchestre Rvolutionnaire et Romantique performed a semi-staged version here. The music is so energetic, so attention-seeking, so packed with masterful orchestration that it did not matter that the semi-staging was lacking.

Home to Puccini's masterpiece - his triptych of one-act operas, 'Il Trittico' - the Royal Opera House proved that for impressive opera London is the place to be. Together 'Suor Angelica', 'Il tabarro' and 'Gianni Schicchi' follow a loose trajectory from hell through purgatory to paradise. Full of orchestral magic and tough choral writing, they form an emotional roller-coaster.

The winning partnership of Royal Opera principal conductor Antonio Pappano and maverick director Richard Jones helped the production. Thanks to Pappano's detailed conducting and Jones's masterstroke of setting the piece in a children's hospital, there were plenty of weepy moments.

In 'Il tabarro', Lucio Gallo was not quite hoary enough as the resentful Michele in this grim take on Parisian barge life, while Eva-Maria Westbroek overplayed the trashy element of his wife Giorgetta. The ensemble comedy that is 'Gianni Schicchi' boasted the perfect line-up and it was kept sharp and detailed, while Puccini's immaculate sense of comic timing was maximised to the full. The audience were left laughing more than they had ever done before in an opera house setting.




About the Author: